OHO Orders by Topic

Click on one of the topics below to see relevant OHO orders.
View: Chronologically | By Topic | By Rule

Admissibility — Misc.

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 30, 2017 2013037401001 Sua Sponte Order Striking Portions of Respondent’s Answer and Precluding Immaterial and Impertinent Evidence 17-01
Jan 20, 2016 2015044960501 Order Denying Motion to Admit Newly Discovered Evidence, dated January 20, 2016. 16-01
May 18, 2011 2007010580702 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion Concerning the Testimony of MO, MB, and JF, and Denying the Respondent’s Motion to Exclude Their Testimony 11-06
Feb 15, 2007 2005000316701 Order Ruling on Department of Enforcement's (1) Objections to Witnesses and Documents, (2) Motion to Partially Strike Respondents' Pre-Hearing Brief, (3) Motion in Limine, and (4) Motion for Ruling on the Admissibility of Documents and Business Records 07-04
Jan 20, 2006 C05050015 Order Number 06-14 (C05050015)Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference and Rulings on Motions in Limine 06-14
Apr 4, 2005 CAF040002 Order Denying Respondents' Motion in Limine to Preclude Complainant from Using New Simulation Model 05-13
Oct 29, 2003 CAF030008 Order Regarding the Department's Motions in Limine 03-22
Jul 31, 2000 CMS960174 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Sever and Preclude 00-20
Mar 26, 2000 CAF980002 Order Regarding Respondents' Motion to Preclude Designation of Transcripts; Respondents' Motion for a Protective Order; and Enforcement's Motion for Post-Hearing Submissions in Excess of Twenty-Five Pages 00-07

Admissions and Denials

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Dec 20, 2017 2016047565702 Order Regarding Motion for Order Directing Zipper to File a Proposed Answer 17-14
Apr 17, 2006 E1020040926-01 Order Directing the Respondents to File a Proper Answer to the Complaint 06-29
Jun 28, 1999 CAF990007 Order Granting Respondents' Motion for Reconsideration 99-13

Affirmative Defenses

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 10, 2018 2014042606902 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion for Rule-Compliant Answer 18-03
Jun 11, 2007 E102003025201 Order Ruling on (1) Objections to Witnesses, (2) Motion to Substitute Exhibit, (3) Motions in Limine, and (4) Motions to Strike the Respondents' Affirmative Defenses 07-21
May 11, 2007 2005001449202 Interim Scheduling and Case Management Order 07-18
Jun 30, 2005 C05050015 Order Denying Motions to Quash 05-27
May 17, 2005 C9B040098 Order Granting Motions to Strike Affirmative Defenses and for Leave to Offer Expert Testimony 05-21
Jul 1, 2004 C9B030076 Order Correcting Order Dismissing Affirmative Defense and Denying Respondent's Motion to Reconsider 04-10
Jun 22, 2004 C9B030076 Order Dismissing Affirmative Defense 04-07
Jun 1, 2004 C8A030100 Order Denying Motion for Leave to File Amended Answer 04-03
Apr 8, 2003 CAF020023 Order Granting Complainant's Motion in Limine 03-08
Apr 23, 2002 CAF000027 Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference 02-06
Jan 26, 2001 CAF000045 Order Denying Complainant's Motion to Strike Affirmative Defenses 01-02
Jul 7, 1999 C8A990015 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Complainant's Motion to Strike Affirmative Defenses 99-10
Apr 27, 1999 C11970032 Order Granting Motion to Strike Affirmative Defenses 99-07
Oct 2, 1998 CAF980022 Order Denying in Part and Granting in Part Enforcement's Motion to Strike Affirmative Defenses and Denying Motion to Dismiss 98-29
Dec 26, 1997 CAF970001 Order Regarding Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings 97-17
Dec 26, 1997 CAF970001 Order Regarding Motion to Strike Affirmative Defenses 97-18

Amendment

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Dec 8, 2014 2011030781201 Order (1) Denying Respondent’s Motion to Dismiss, (2) Granting in Part Enforcement’s Motion to Strike, and (3) Directing Respondent to File an Amended Answer 14-07
Jun 1, 2004 C8A030100 Order Denying Motion for Leave to File Amended Answer 04-03

Answer

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 30, 2017 2013037401001 Sua Sponte Order Striking Portions of Respondent’s Answer and Precluding Immaterial and Impertinent Evidence 17-01

Applicability of Code of Procedure

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Sep 30, 1999 CMS920002 Order Directing Complainant to Comply with Rule 9251 99-19

Arbitration Cases

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jul 29, 2009 ARB090054 Order Dismissing Proceeding for Failure to State a Defense 09-01
Dec 7, 2007 ARB070050 Order Deeming Request for Hearing Abandoned and Terminating Expedited Proceeding and Notice that Respondent's Suspension Is in Effect 07-41
Jun 13, 2007 ARB070023 Order Deeming (1) Respondent's Defense Abandoned, (2) the Hearing Waived, and (3) the NASD Suspension Notice Final 07-30
Oct 4, 2006 ARB060029 Order Dismissing Defense and Granting Respondents Leave to File a Motion for Leave to Amend Their Request for Hearing 06-44
Sep 28, 2006 ARB060022 Order Deeming Defense as Abandoned, Hearing as Waived, and NASD Suspension Notice as Final 06-41
Sep 15, 2006 ARB060023 Order Overruling Objection to Telephonic Hearing 06-39
Apr 18, 2006 ARB060010 Order Dismissing Request for Hearing 06-31
Apr 12, 2005 ARB050010 Order Deeming Defense as Abandoned, Hearing as Waived, and Nasd Suspension Notice as Final 05-16
Mar 1, 2005 ARB050002 Order Granting Enforcement's Rule 9559(M) Motion and Dismissing Proceeding 05-05
Jan 14, 2005 ARB040045 Order Deeming Defense as Abandoned, Hearing as Waived, and Nasd Suspension Notice as Final 05-02
Oct 19, 2004 ARB040033 Order Denying Respondent's Motion To Dismiss 04-28
Oct 6, 2004 ARB040029 Order Deeming Defense as Abandoned, Hearing as Waived, and Nasd Suspension Notice as Final 04-25
Mar 28, 2004 DFC040005 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Dismiss the Suspension Proceeding 04-02

Authentication

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Nov 18, 2005 CAF040058 Order Regarding Admissibility of Tape Recordings and Transcripts 05-40
Oct 28, 2004 CAF040020 Order Ruling On Pre-Hearing Motions 04-29
Feb 7, 2003 C07020067 Order Granting Motion in Limine 03-14

Bankruptcy

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Feb 5, 1998 CAF970002 Order Regarding Severance 98-17
Dec 29, 1997 CAF970002 Order Regarding Respondent Motion for an Extension of Time to Answer 97-19

Brady motions

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Mar 18, 2011 2007011413501 Order Denying the Respondents’ Motion to Compel Production of Documents; for Production of a List of Withheld Documents; and to Extend Deadlines and Hearing Dates 11-03
Oct 8, 2010 2008014621701 Order Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Documents and List of Withheld Documents 10-06
Nov 24, 2009 2006006259501 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Compel Production of List of Withheld Documents 09-04
Aug 16, 2007 E112005002003 Order Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Identification and Production of Withheld Documents 07-36
Oct 6, 2004 CAF040002 Motion To Compel Compliance With Procedural Rule 9251 and Denying the Respondents' Motions for Sanctions and for Leave to File a Reply 04-26
Oct 4, 2004 CAF030014 Order Partially Granting the Respondent's Motion to Reconsider Discovery Requests 04-23
Mar 17, 2004 CAF030014 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition and Request for Preclusion Order Based Upon Unfair Investigatory Process 04-01
Oct 26, 2003 CAF030011 Order Granting in Part Respondent 1 and Respondent 2's Motion for Production of Documents Under Rule 9251(a)(3) 03-21
Oct 15, 2003 CAF030008 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Compel Production of Information Regarding Withheld Documents 03-20
Oct 4, 2001 CAF000045 Order Regarding Production of Documents 01-16
May 21, 2001 CAF000013 Order Denying Respondents' Motion For The Production Of Documents From Nasdaq And Requiring The Complainant To File A Declaration Certifying That It Has Complied With Rule 9251 01-14
May 17, 2001 CAF000045 Order Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel the Production of Documents and for a List of Withheld Documents 01-13
Jul 28, 2000 C9B000007 Order Denying Motion to Compel Production of Documents 00-19
Jun 21, 1999 CAF980002 Order Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Documents 99-12

Cease and Desist Proceedings

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Mar 2, 2005 CAF040056 Order Denying Enforcement's Motion to Modify Permanent Cease and Desist Order 05-06
Sep 17, 2004 CAF040056 Order Denying Respondent's Application to Vacate the Temporary Cease and Desist Order 04-20
Aug 2, 2004 CAF040056 Order Granting in Part, and Denying in Part, Enforcement's Motion for Leave to Offer Telephone Testimony 04-13

Character

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 13, 2006 CLI050016 Order Granting, In Part, Complainant's Motion to Preclude and Denying Respondent's Motion to Limit Complainant's Evidence 06-12

Combined Pre-Hearing Motions

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Mar 3, 2016 2014040968501 Omnibus Order on Pre-Hearing Motions 16-13

Compelling Attendance

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 4, 2008 2005003437102 Order Granting Respondent's Motion Pursuant to Rule 9252 to Compel Testimony at Hearing 08-08
Feb 8, 2006 CAF040058 Order Denying Respondents' Motion to Invoke Procedural Rule 8210 06-18
Jun 23, 2005 C3A040045 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Compel and Motion Pursuant to Rule 9252 05-28
May 27, 2005 C06040023 Order Denying Request for Subpoena 05-22
Jun 18, 2004 C3A040006 Order Denying Motion to Compel Testimony 04-06
Apr 23, 2004 C9B040033 Pre-Hearing Order 04-24
Oct 9, 2000 C07000023 Pre-Hearing Order 00-30
Jul 20, 2000 C3A000007 Order Denying Respondents' Motions to Compel Testimony 00-18
Sep 27, 1999 CAF980002 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Reconsideration Regarding Invocation of Rule 8210 Pursuant to Rule 9252 99-18

Complaint, Amendment of

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Oct 31, 2007 20070077587 Order Resolving Certain Pre-Hearing Motions 07-38
May 11, 2007 2005001449202 Interim Scheduling and Case Management Order 07-18
Apr 20, 2001 C10010004 Order Granting Complainant's Motion to Amend the Complaint; Denying Complainant's Motion for Leave to File a Reply to Respondent's Opposition to Motion to Amend; and Denying Respondent's Motion to Sever 01-08
Jan 27, 1998 CAF970011 Order Granting Department of Enforcement's Motion to Amend the Complaint 98-12

Consolidation, Severance and Bifurcation

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 17, 2003 C01020025 Order Denying Motion to Bifurcate Hearing 03-09
May 15, 2002 CAF010021 Order Denying Motion to Sever 02-10
Apr 20, 2001 C10010004 Order Granting Complainant's Motion to Amend the Complaint; Denying Complainant's Motion for Leave to File a Reply to Respondent's Opposition to Motion to Amend; and Denying Respondent's Motion to Sever 01-08
Jul 31, 2000 CMS960174 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Sever and Preclude 00-20
May 7, 1999 C8A990015 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Separate Proceedings and Stay of Action 99-08
May 7, 1999 CAF980031 Order Denying Motions to Sever 99-09
Feb 5, 1998 CAF970002 Order Regarding Severance 98-17
Dec 18, 1997 C05970037 Order Granting Motion for Consolidation of Disciplinary Proceedings 97-14

Constitutional Defenses

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jun 4, 2003 C9A030006 Order Denying Motion for Summary Disposition 03-15
Apr 17, 2001 CAF000013 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Summary Disposition and Motion to Dismiss the Fourth Cause of Action and Supplementing Order Granting Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition on Cause Four of the Complaint Against Respondents 01-07
Jun 28, 1999 CAF990007 Order Granting Respondents' Motion for Reconsideration 99-13

Consumer Protection

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jul 28, 2016 2013035817701 Protective Order Governing Personal Confidential Information 16-19

Contempt

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 31, 2006 C3A030008 Order Holding Respondent In Default and In Contempt, and Directing Complainant to File a Motion for Entry of Default Decision 06-15

Content

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 10, 2018 2014042606902 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion for Rule-Compliant Answer 18-03
Dec 20, 2017 2016047565702 Order Regarding Motion for Order Directing Zipper to File a Proper Answer 17-22
Dec 28, 2006 2005001819101 Order Granting Complainant's Motion to Strike in Part the Introduction to Respondent's Answer 06-57
Apr 3, 2003 C3B020015 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition 03-06

Continuance / Stay

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Nov 23, 2016 20080148227-02 Order Deferring Ruling on Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings. 16-31
Oct 31, 2016 2014042524301 Order Regarding Respondent’s Motions to Stay Case Management and Scheduling Order and to Strike and/or For a More Definite Statement. 16-28
Sep 7, 2016 2013038986001 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Continue Hearing 16‐25
Jan 2, 2013 2009019108901 Order Denying Motion by Respondent 1 for an Extension of Time – Hearing 13-01
Oct 17, 2012 2010024320101 Order to Provide Verification in Support of Request for Continuance of Hearing 12-05
Sep 7, 2011 2009017798201 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Stay of Hearing 11-08
Jun 1, 2011 2010021196801 Order Regarding Respondent’s Motion to Stay 11-07
Mar 22, 2007 C10040052 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Partial Summary Disposition 07-11
Sep 13, 2006 E102003025201 Order Granting Motion to Adjourn Proceeding and Setting Pre-Hearing Conference 06-37
Aug 18, 2006 E0220030845-01 Order Postponing Hearing 06-33
May 5, 2006 CAF030007 Order Granting Complainant's Motion to Withdraw the Complaint, with Prejudice CAF030007
Mar 23, 2006 CLI050007 Order Precluding Evidence and Denying Respondent's Motion to Continue Hearing 06-28
Mar 15, 2006 CLG050021 Order Denying Complainant's Motion to Continue Hearing 06-24
Jan 6, 2006 CLI050004 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Adjourn Hearing 06-01
Nov 15, 2005 CMS040165 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Reconsideration of Scheduling Order 05-38
Jan 14, 2003 C9A020018 Order Denying Request for Postponement of Hearing 03-03
Aug 3, 2000 C01000003 Order Denying Respondents' Request for a Second Continuance of the Hearing 00-22
Oct 23, 1998 C06980015 Order Denying Motion to Stay Proceeding 98-31
Oct 2, 1998 CAF970011 Order Denying Motions for Interlocutory Appeal and to Reconsider Denial of Motion to Stay the Proceeding 98-28
Mar 10, 1998 CMS970026 Final Pre-Hearing Conference Order, Order Granting Respondents' Motion to Adjourn the March 17, 1998 Hearing, Order Rejecting Respondents' Contested Offer of Settlement, and Order Denying the Department of Enforcement's Motion for Partial Summary Disposition 98-21
Feb 2, 1998 C04970029 Order Staying Proceeding 98-16
Jan 8, 1998 C10970172 Order Denying Respondent's Request for Indefinite Postponement 98-3
Dec 15, 1997 C05970037 Order Denying Motion to Stay Proceeding 97-13

Counsel as Witness

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
May 18, 2011 2007010580702 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion Concerning the Testimony of MO, MB, and JF, and Denying the Respondent’s Motion to Exclude Their Testimony 11-06

Counsel for Witnesses

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Sep 5, 2017 2016051925301 Order Granting Motion to Permit Witness Counsel to be Present During Testimony 17-17
Aug 24, 2016 2014043020901 Order Granting Joint Motion to Permit Witnesses to Have Counsel Present During Testimony 16-23
Feb 8, 2011 2006007105101 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Summary Disposition 11-02
Sep 8, 2008 2006005523401 Order Granting Enforcement's Motion to Permit Counsel for Non-Party Witnesses to Appear at Hearing 08-13
Sep 28, 2006 E8A2003091501 Order Granting Motion for to Permit Certain Witnesses to Have Counsel Present 06-42
Oct 5, 2005 CLG050049 Order Regarding Attendance of Wittnesses' Counsel at Hearing 05-32
Jan 31, 2000 C9A990007 Order Granting Motion for Order Permitting Certain Witnesses to Have Counsel Present 00-03

Criminal Proceedings — Effect of

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 17, 2001 CAF000013 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Summary Disposition and Motion to Dismiss the Fourth Cause of Action and Supplementing Order Granting Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition on Cause Four of the Complaint Against Respondents 01-07
Feb 15, 2001 CMS000157 Order Granting Respondent's Motion to Exclude Documents 01-05
Oct 23, 1998 C06980015 Order Denying Motion to Stay Proceeding 98-31
Feb 2, 1998 C04970029 Order Staying Proceeding 98-16
Jan 8, 1998 C10970172 Order Denying Respondent's Request for Indefinite Postponement 98-3
Dec 15, 1997 C05970037 Order Denying Motion to Stay Proceeding 97-13

Deadline for Filing

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Dec 20, 2017 2016047565702 Order Regarding Motion for Order Directing Zipper to File a Proposed Answer 17-14
Jul 18, 2000 C10000046 Order Regarding Respondent's Motion for Leave to File a Late Answer 00-17
Dec 2, 1998 C06980021 Order Denying in Part and Granting in Part Respondent's Motion to Stay Default Decision, for an Extension of Time to File Answer, and for Extension of Time to Comply with Request for Information 98-34
Dec 29, 1997 CAF970002 Order Regarding Respondent Motion for an Extension of Time to Answer 97-19
Nov 14, 1997 C10970141 Order Extending Time for Respondents to Answer 97-8
Nov 13, 1997 CAF970002 Order Regarding Motion of Respondents Requesting an Extension of Time to Answer, a More Definite Answer, and an Updated Service List 97-7
Nov 11, 1997 CAF970002 Order Denying Motion of Respondents and for Extension of Time to Answer 97-6
Sep 18, 1997 C10970158 Order Extending Time for Respondents to Answer 97-2
Sep 15, 1997 C10970142 Order Denying Request for Extension of Time in Which to Answer 97-1

Decision

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Nov 26, 2004 C9B030076 Order Denying Respondent's Amended Motion to Reconsider Order Denying Motion to Dismiss 04-09

Default

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Sep 22, 2011 20090192254 Memorandum Opinion and Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Set Aside Default Decision 11-09
Mar 18, 2008 2006005849101 Order Denying Motion to Set Aside Default Decision 08-04
Sep 20, 2006 ARB060029 Order Clarifying Agenda for Pre-Hearing Conference 06-40
Jan 31, 2006 C3A030008 Order Holding Respondent In Default and In Contempt, and Directing Complainant to File a Motion for Entry of Default Decision 06-15
Jan 9, 2006 C8A050041 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Set Aside Default 06-03
Apr 6, 2001 C07000084 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Reconsider and to Set Aside Default Decision 01-06
Mar 26, 2000 CAF980002 Order Regarding Respondents' Motion to Preclude Designation of Transcripts; Respondents' Motion for a Protective Order; and Enforcement's Motion for Post-Hearing Submissions in Excess of Twenty-Five Pages 00-07
Mar 9, 2000 C8A990032 Order Vacating Default Against Respondent, Granting Complainant Leave to Re-Serve the Complaint, and Setting a Briefing Schedule on the Issue of Jurisdiction 00-05
Sep 23, 1999 C02980034 Order Denying Motion for Entry Of Default Decision Against Respondent and Granting Enforcement Leave to Re-Serve the Complaint 99-16
Jan 6, 1999 CAF980002 Order Denying "Notice of Objection to Order" and Rejecting "Response to Order to Show Cause" of Respondents 99-01
Dec 2, 1998 C06980021 Order Denying in Part and Granting in Part Respondent's Motion to Stay Default Decision, for an Extension of Time to File Answer, and for Extension of Time to Comply with Request for Information 98-34
Sep 16, 1998 C9A970045 Order Denying Motion for Entry of Default Decision 98-27
Jan 13, 1998 C10970141 Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration of Order Setting Deadline for Filing Motion for Entry of Default Decision 98-5
Jan 12, 1998 C3A970074 Order Setting Second Pre-Hearing Conference 98-4
Dec 9, 1997 C10970128 Order Regarding Department of Enforcements Contact with Respondent's Counsel 97-11

Discovery and Document Requests

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Nov 14, 2016 2014040476901 Order Denying Respondents’ Motion Under Rule 9252 For Issuance of Requests for Documents and Information. 16-30

Disqualification of Counsel / Conflicts

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jun 3, 2013 2009019042402 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Disqualify Josefina Martinez and Motion to Compel Testimony and Production of Documents by Josefina Martinez 13-04
May 18, 2011 2007010580702 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion Concerning the Testimony of MO, MB, and JF, and Denying the Respondent’s Motion to Exclude Their Testimony 11-06
Aug 19, 2005 CMS040165 Order on Remand From the National Adjudicatory Council Granting Complinant's Motion to Disqualify Counsel for Respondents 1 and 2 05-31
Oct 28, 2004 CAF040020 Order Ruling On Pre-Hearing Motions 04-29
Oct 29, 2003 CAF030008 Order Regarding the Department's Motions in Limine 03-22
Apr 30, 2003 CMS020143 Order Denying Complainant's Motion to Disqualify Counsel 03-10
Jul 20, 1998 C10970141 Order Regarding Pre-Hearing Conference 98-25
Jan 29, 1998 CAF970011 Order Denying Motion to Disqualify Counsel for Complainant and Hearing Panelists 98-14

Disqualification of Hearing Officers

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Aug 4, 2005 C9B040098 Order Denying Motion to Disqualify Hearing Officer 05-29
Feb 28, 2005 C9B040059 Order Denying Motion to Disqualify Hearing Officer Witherspoon 05-04
Jan 28, 2002 CAF010028 Order Denying Motion To Disqualify Hearing Officer 02-02
Jun 13, 2000 CMS000015 Notice of Withdrawal of Hearing Officer 00-13
Mar 31, 1999 C11970032 Order Denying Motion to Disqualify Hearing Officer 99-04
Jan 29, 1998 CAF970011 Order Denying Motion to Disqualify Counsel for Recusal of Hearing Officer 98-15
Oct 29, 1997 CMS960105 Order Denying Motion for Disqualification of Hearing Officer 97-4

Disqualification of Hearing Panelists

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 10, 2006 CLI050016 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Disqualify Hearing Panelist 06-06
Feb 8, 1999 CAF980002 Order Denying Motion to Disqualify a Panelist 99-02
Jan 29, 1998 CAF970011 Order Denying Motion to Disqualify Counsel for Complainant and Hearing Panelists 98-14
Jan 29, 1998 CAF970011 Order Denying Motion to Disqualify Counsel for Recusal of Hearing Officer 98-15

Document production – motions to compel under Rule 9252

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 21, 2017 2012032019101 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Respondents’ Motion Pursuant to FINRA Rules 8210 and 9252. 17-12
Apr 11, 2017 2014042524301 Order Regarding Respondent’s Interrogatories, Requests for Production of Documents, and Requests for Admissions 17-10
Apr 11, 2017 2014044985401 Order Granting Respondent’s Request for an Order of Production. 17-11
Mar 21, 2017 2014038847602 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Compel Discovery. 17-06
Mar 21, 2017 2014038847602 Order Denying Motion to Quash and Requiring Respondent to Respond to Rule 8210 Requests No Later Than March 31, 2017. 17-08
Mar 8, 2017 2015044921601 Order Denying Respondent’s Discovery Motion. 17-04
Dec 28, 2016 2014042690502 Order Granting, in Part, Respondents' Motion Requesting Issuance of FINRA Rule 8210 Requests. 16-34
Nov 14, 2016 2014040476901 Order Denying Respondents’ Motion Under Rule 9252 For Issuance of Requests for Documents and Information. 16-30
May 20, 2016 2013038333001 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Request for Documents and Information 16-17
Mar 25, 2016 2015044379701 Order Denying Rule 9252 Request 16-14
Mar 11, 2016 2013038418201 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Compel Member Firm to Produce Additional Documents. 16-12
Mar 4, 2016 2013036836801 Order Denying Respondent’s Rule 9252 Request 16-10
Feb 29, 2016 2014043020901 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion Pursuant to FINRA Rule 9252 and Granting Respondent Leave to Supplement 16-07
Feb 25, 2016 2014043020901 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Compel Production of Documents 16-08
Jan 27, 2015 2012034936005 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Compel Production of Documents and Rule 9252 Motion 15-05
Sep 30, 2014 2012032519101 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Production of Documents 14-04
Jun 12, 2013 2011025780101 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Compel the Department of Enforcement to Produce Withheld Documents 13-05
May 2, 2013 2009017529101 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Compel Production of Documents and a List of Withheld Documents. 13-06
May 2, 2013 2009017529101 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Compel Production of Documents and a List of Withheld Documents 13-03
Aug 30, 2012 2010023367001 Order Denying Respondent 1’s Motion to Compel Production of Withheld Documents 12-04
Aug 27, 2008 2005003188901 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Compel Production of Documents 08-12
Jun 26, 2007 20050000720-02 Order Denying Respondent 2's Motion to Compel Production of Documents and Directing Respondent 2 to Supplement His Motion for a Rule 9252 Order 07-25
Oct 31, 2006 2005000127502 Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference Modifying Order Precluding Respondents from Introducing Evidence at the Hearing and Dismissing the Third Cause of Complaint 06-50
Oct 11, 2006 EAF0400300001 Order Denying Respondents' Rule 9252 Motion for the Production of Data, Documents and Testimony 06-47
Feb 9, 2006 E9B2003033501 Order Granting Respondent's Motion for Issuance Of Rule 8210 Requests for Information 06-19
Jan 12, 2006 C07050029 Order Denying Complainant's Motion to Preclude the Respondent from Offering Evidence, Revising the Pre-Hearing Schedule, and Denying Respondent's Motion to Reconsider Denial of Motion to Compel Discovery 06-08
Jan 11, 2006 E9B2003033501 Order Denying In Part and Granting In Part Respondent's Motion to Compel Discovery 06-07
Jan 10, 2006 E8A2004065102 Order Requiring Respondent to Supplement His Rule 9252 Request 06-04
Jan 10, 2006 CLI050016 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Compel Discovery 06-05
Dec 14, 2005 C07050029 Order Denying Respondent 1's Motion to Postpone the Hearing and to Compel Discovery 05-41
Jun 23, 2005 C3A040045 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Compel and Motion Pursuant to Rule 9252 05-28
Apr 7, 2005 CAF040058 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Leave to Introduce Expert Testimony and to Compel Production of Documents 05-15
Jan 14, 2005 CAF040058 Order Denying Respondents' Motion Pursuant to Rule 9252 and for an Extension of Time 05-01
Oct 4, 2004 CAF030014 Order Partially Granting the Respondent's Motion to Reconsider Discovery Requests 04-23
Sep 9, 2004 C9B040033 Order Requiring Respondent to Supplement his Rule 9252 Requests 04-17
Aug 17, 2004 C3A030050 Order Granting in Part, and Denying in Part, Respondent's Motion for Issuance of Rule 8210 Requests Pursuant to Rule 9252 04-14
Jun 10, 2004 C9B040020 Order Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Discovery 04-04
Sep 18, 2003 C3A030001 Order Denying Motion for Issuance of 8210 Requests 03-17
May 21, 2001 CAF000013 Order Denying Respondents' Motion For The Production Of Documents From Nasdaq And Requiring The Complainant To File A Declaration Certifying That It Has Complied With Rule 9251 01-14
May 11, 2001 C05010012 Order Granting Respondent's Request for Production of Documents Pursuant to NASD Procedural Rule 9252 01-12
Oct 9, 2000 C07000023 Pre-Hearing Order 00-30
May 17, 2000 C10970143 Order Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Information and Documents from Customer Witnesses 00-12
May 18, 1998 CAF970002 Order Denying Motions for Production of Documents Pursuant to Rule 9252 98-24
Jan 22, 1998 CMS970026 Order Granting the Department of Enforcement's Motion for Telephone Testimony, Denying Respondents' Motion for Use of an Expert Witness and Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Documents 98-11
Jan 2, 1998 C10970164 Pre-Hearing Scheduling Order and Rulings on Respondent's Discovery Motion 98-1

Effect of Appeals

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Mar 2, 2005 CAF040056 Order Denying Enforcement's Motion to Modify Permanent Cease and Desist Order 05-06
Oct 18, 1999 CMS920002 Order Denying Motion to Stay Proceedings and to Vacate Current Scheduling Order 99-20

Equitable Defenses

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Aug 8, 2008 E3A20030495-01 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Dismiss the Complaint 08-11
Apr 4, 2008 2005003437102 Order Granting Department of Enforcement's Motion to Strike Respondent's Unclean Hands Affirmative Defense 08-06
Oct 29, 2003 CAF030008 Order Regarding the Department's Motions in Limine 03-22
May 10, 2001 C3A000056 Order Denying Motion to Dismiss 01-11
May 1, 2001 C3A000056 Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration 01-10
Jul 7, 1999 C8A990015 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Complainant's Motion to Strike Affirmative Defenses 99-10

Evidence

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jul 28, 2016 20120342425-01 Order Concerning Parties’ Motion for Leave to Present Expert Testimony 16-20

Ex Parte Communications

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 29, 2002 C01010017 Order Pursuant To Conduct Rule 9143 02-07
Mar 31, 1999 C11970032 Order Denying Motion to Disqualify Hearing Officer 99-04

Exhibits

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jun 27, 2007 E102003025201 Order Regarding Pre-Hearing Motions 07-26
Feb 16, 2007 2005000316701 Order Ruling on Respondents' Motions to Strike Department of Enforcement's Exhibits 07-05
Apr 25, 2006 CLG050021 Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference and Ruling on Motions in Limine 06-32
Oct 30, 2005 C3A040045 Order (1) Granting Complainant's Motion for Leave to Offer Telephone Testimony and Denying Respondent's Motion to Postpone the Hearing; (2) Granting Complainant's Motion in Limine; and (3) Denying Respondent's Motion in Limine 05-37

Expert Witnesses / Testimony Allowed

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Mar 21, 2017 2013035817701 Order 1) Granting Enforcement’s Motion For Leave to Permit Expert Testimony and 2) Amending Case Management and Scheduling Order Regarding Filing Exhibits. 17-07
Dec 28, 2016 2014042690502 Order Granting, in Part, Respondents' Motion Requesting Issuance of FINRA Rule 8210 Requests. 16-34
Jul 28, 2016 20120342425-01 Order Concerning Parties’ Motion for Leave to Present Expert Testimony 16-20
Feb 22, 2016 2014040501801 Order Denying Motion for Permission to Present Expert Testimony 16-06
Feb 3, 2015 2011025706401 Order Granting Department of Enforcement’s Motion for Leave to Offer Expert Testimony 15-04
Nov 9, 2012 2010020846601 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion to Offer Expert Testimony and Respondent’s Motion to Allow Expert Testimony 12-07
May 16, 2011 2007011413501 Order Denying Respondents’ Motion to Exclude Certain Portions of the Expert Report of HGF and to Preclude His Expert Testimony on the Issue of Suitability 11-05
Oct 23, 2006 EAF0300770001 Order Permitting Expert Testimony 06-49
Apr 17, 2006 E0220030425-01 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Disqualify Expert Witness 06-30
Apr 12, 2006 CLG050021 Order Partially Granting the Complainant's Motion to Disqualify Expert Witness 06-26
Mar 15, 2006 E0220030425-01 Order Granting the Parties' Motions for Leave to Introduce Testimony of Handwriting Experts and Denying Respondent's Motion to Introduce Testimony of a Polygraph Examiner 06-25
Oct 19, 2005 CAF040058 Order Granting the Parties' Motions for Leave to Introduce Expert Testimony 05-35
May 17, 2005 C9B040098 Order Granting Motions to Strike Affirmative Defenses and for Leave to Offer Expert Testimony 05-21
Apr 5, 2005 CAF040002 Order Denying Complainant's Objection to Expert Testimony of Paul Mason 05-14
Jul 30, 2004 C9B040013 Order Granting Respondents' Motion to Introduce Expert Testimony 04-12
Oct 15, 2003 C01020022 Order Granting the Parties' Motions for Leave to Introduce Expert Testimony 03-19
Jul 17, 1999 C8A990015 Hearing Panel Order Granting Respondent'sMotion for Leave to Introduce Expert Witness Testimony 99-11
Mar 22, 1999 C02980073 Order Granting Enforcement's Motion for Leave to Introduce Expert Witness Testimony 99-03

Expert Witnesses / Testimony Disallowed or Decision Deferred

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Mar 16, 2017 201504421601 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Leave to Present Expert Testimony 17-05
Feb 24, 2017 2014042059701 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Permission to Offer Expert Testimony. 17-03
Jul 28, 2016 20120342425-01 Order Concerning Parties’ Motion for Leave to Present Expert Testimony 16-20
Jan 29, 2016 2014040295201 Order Denying Respondents’ Motion for Expert Testimony 16-02
Apr 8, 2015 2011025622001 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Leave to Permit Expert Testimony 15-08
Sep 9, 2014 2011025617702 Order Denying Respondents’ Motion to Permit Expert Testimony 14-05
Mar 14, 2012 2009018771602 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Present Expert Witness 12-01
Mar 24, 2011 2009017798201 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Leave to Offer Expert Testimony 11-04
May 28, 2010 200011592201 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Leave to Offer Expert Testimony 10-03
Feb 26, 2008 2005003437102 Order Denying Motion for Leave to Offer Expert Testimony 08-02
May 17, 2007 E102003025201 Order Denying Respondents' Request for Leave to Offer Expert Testimony 07-20
Feb 13, 2007 2005000094001 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Leave to Offer Expert Testimony 07-03
Nov 16, 2006 2005000316701 Order (1) Granting Complainant's Motion in Limine; (2) Denying Complainant's Motion to Sequester Witnesses, Without Prejudice; (3) Denying Respondents' Motions to Dismiss; (4) Denying Respondents' Motion to Strike; (5) Granting, in Part, Respondents' Motion To Preclude; (6) Denying, in Part, and Deferring, in Part, Respondents' Motion For Leave to Present Expert Testimony and (7) Denying Respondents' Motion for Leave to File a Compilation of Motions, Briefs and Rulings 06-55
Mar 15, 2006 E0220030425-01 Order Granting the Parties' Motions for Leave to Introduce Testimony of Handwriting Experts and Denying Respondent's Motion to Introduce Testimony of a Polygraph Examiner 06-25
Mar 3, 2006 E9B2003033501 Order Sustaining Complainant's Objections to Respondent's Expert Witness Designation and Report 06-20
Jan 20, 2006 C05050015 Order Number 06-14 (C05050015)Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference and Rulings on Motions in Limine 06-14
Dec 15, 2005 CE3050003 Order Deferring Ruling on Joint Motion for Leave to Offer Expert Testimony 05-42
May 5, 2005 C02040032 Order Denying Respondent's Request for Leave to Offer Expert Testimony 05-19
Apr 21, 2005 CAF040070 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Leave to Introduce Expert Testimony 05-17
Apr 7, 2005 CAF040058 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Leave to Introduce Expert Testimony and to Compel Production of Documents 05-15
Mar 29, 2005 C01040017 Order Granting in Part the Department's Motion to Preclude the Respondent from Introducing Evidence at the Hearing 05-11
Jul 7, 2003 CAF020053 Order on Respondent's Expert Witness Designation 03-16
Apr 23, 2002 CAF000027 Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference 02-06
Apr 4, 2002 C02010041 Pre-Hearing Order 02-05
May 23, 2001 CAF000013 Order Granting Complainant's Motion to Preclude the Introduction of Expert Testimony 01-15
Oct 6, 2000 C9B000013 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Leave to Offer Expert Witness Testimony 00-29
Jul 5, 2000 C01000003 Order Denying Respondents' Motion Seeking Leave to Introduce Expert Witness Testimony 00-15
May 5, 2000 CAF990007 Order Denying Respondents' Motion Seeking Leave to Introduce Expert Witness Testimony 00-11
Mar 10, 1998 C05970035 Order Granting in Part Motion of Complainant to Exclude Respondents' Expert Witness and Certain Other Witnesses 98-22
Jan 22, 1998 CMS970026 Order Granting the Department of Enforcement's Motion for Telephone Testimony, Denying Respondents' Motion for Use of an Expert Witness and Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Documents 98-11
Nov 15, 1997 C07970055 Final Pre-hearing Conference Order 97-9

Filing by Representative of Respondent

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 21, 1998 C10970176 Order as to Respondent 98-10
Dec 19, 1997 C01970032 Order Striking Answer Filed on Behalf of and Directing the Department of Enforcement to Send a Second Notice of Complaint 97-15

General

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 11, 2017 2014042524301 Order Regarding Respondent’s Interrogatories, Requests for Production of Documents, and Requests for Admissions 17-10
Dec 14, 2016 2015044823501 Order Denying Respondent Beyn’s Motion for Additional Discovery. 16-33
May 20, 2016 2013038333001 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Request for Documents and Information 16-17
Mar 30, 2016 2013036681701 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion for Leave to Withhold Documents From Discovery. 16-15
Feb 3, 2016 2012033393401 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Respondent’s Motion in Limine to Exclude the Testimony of KA, BS, and MC. 16-04
Jan 24, 2014 2010023218601 Order Denying Respondent’s Discovery Motions. 14-03
Apr 5, 2012 2011029760201 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Leave to Serve Limited Discovery 12-02
Mar 18, 2011 2007011413501 Order Denying the Respondents’ Motion to Compel Production of Documents; for Production of a List of Withheld Documents; and to Extend Deadlines and Hearing Dates 11-03
Jun 13, 2007 20050000720-02 Order Prohibiting Use of Subpoenas 07-24
Jun 12, 2007 2005000191701 Order Denying Respondent 3's Two Discovery Requests 07-22
Apr 18, 2007 C11040006 Hearing Panel Order Granting, in Part, and Denying, in Part, Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition 07-16
Mar 7, 2007 2005000316701 Order Granting Motion to Compel or Alternatively to Preclude Oral or Documentary Evidence 07-09
Jan 19, 2006 EAF0400300001 Order Prohibiting Use of Subpeonas 06-11
Jun 14, 2005 CAF040058 Order Prohibiting Use of Subpoenas 05-39
May 17, 2005 C9B040098 Order Denying Relief Sought in Notice to Produce and Application for Protective Order 05-20
Mar 30, 2003 C3B020015 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Respondents' Motion to Compel Discovery 03-05

Hearings — Scheduling, Stays and Logistics

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Nov 23, 2016 20080148227-02 Order Deferring Ruling on Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings. 16-31
Sep 7, 2016 2013038986001 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Continue Hearing 16‐25

Hearsay

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jun 11, 2007 E102003025201 Order Ruling on (1) Objections to Witnesses, (2) Motion to Substitute Exhibit, (3) Motions in Limine, and (4) Motions to Strike the Respondents' Affirmative Defenses 07-21
Feb 16, 2007 2005000316701 Order Ruling on Respondents' Motions to Strike Department of Enforcement's Exhibits 07-05
Feb 15, 2007 2005000316701 Order Ruling on Department of Enforcement's (1) Objections to Witnesses and Documents, (2) Motion to Partially Strike Respondents' Pre-Hearing Brief, (3) Motion in Limine, and (4) Motion for Ruling on the Admissibility of Documents and Business Records 07-04
Oct 30, 2005 C3A040045 Order (1) Granting Complainant's Motion for Leave to Offer Telephone Testimony and Denying Respondent's Motion to Postpone the Hearing; (2) Granting Complainant's Motion in Limine; and (3) Denying Respondent's Motion in Limine 05-37
Oct 28, 2004 CAF040020 Order Ruling On Pre-Hearing Motions 04-29
Aug 4, 1998 CAF970011 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Complainant's Motion in Limine 98-26
Nov 15, 1997 C07970055 Final Pre-hearing Conference Order 97-9

Impeachment

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 20, 1998 C10970161 Order 98-7

Interlocutory

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Oct 2, 1998 CAF970011 Order Denying Motions for Interlocutory Appeal and to Reconsider Denial of Motion to Stay the Proceeding 98-28

Jencks motions

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Mar 18, 2011 2007011413501 Order Denying the Respondents’ Motion to Compel Production of Documents; for Production of a List of Withheld Documents; and to Extend Deadlines and Hearing Dates 11-03
Oct 8, 2010 2008014621701 Order Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Documents and List of Withheld Documents 10-06
Oct 14, 2009 2007009461301 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Compel Production of Witness Statements 09-02
Feb 20, 2007 2005001305701 Order Denying Respondents' Three Discovery Motions 07-06
Feb 7, 2006 C05050008 Order Granting Respondent's Motion for Production of Documents Pursuant to Rule 9253 06-17
Jan 11, 2006 E9B2003033501 Order Denying In Part and Granting In Part Respondent's Motion to Compel Discovery 06-07
Jan 6, 2006 C05050015 Order Granting Respondent 2's Motion for Production of Documents Pursuant to Rule 9253 06-02
Dec 15, 2005 C05050005 Order Denying Respondent's Motion Under Rule 9253 05-43
Oct 28, 2004 CAF040020 Order Ruling On Pre-Hearing Motions 04-29
Jun 15, 2004 CAF030058 Order Granting Respondent's Motion for in Camera Inspection of Documents 04-05
Mar 30, 2003 C3B020015 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Respondents' Motion to Compel Discovery 03-05

Jurisdiction

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Feb 8, 2011 2006007105101 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Summary Disposition 11-02
Feb 25, 2010 20080121376 Order Denying Motion to Dismiss 10-05
May 8, 2002 C10010145 Order Denying Respondent's Motion To Dismiss For Lack Of Jurisdiction 02-08
Jan 22, 2002 C8A010066 Order Denying Respondent's Motion To Dismiss 02-01
Apr 17, 2001 CAF000013 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Summary Disposition and Motion to Dismiss the Fourth Cause of Action and Supplementing Order Granting Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition on Cause Four of the Complaint Against Respondents 01-07
Dec 22, 1998 C9A980032 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction 98-33

Liability for Violations

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 4, 2008 2005003437102 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition 08-07
Oct 16, 2007 2005001919501 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition and Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition 07-37
Dec 30, 1999 CAF990018 Order Denying Motion for Summary Disposition 99-21

Membership Proceedings

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Feb 8, 2002 EQS010002 Order Granting Complainant's Motion To Dismiss 02-04

Miscellaneous

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Nov 23, 2016 20080148227-02 Order Deferring Ruling on Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings. 16-31
Oct 14, 2016 201303641201 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Enforcement’s Motion for Partial Summary Disposition 16-27
Sep 7, 2016 2013038986001 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion to Continue Hearing 16‐25
Aug 30, 2016 2014043020901 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion for Exception From Sequestration. 16-24
Aug 16, 2016 2014039173301 Case Management and Scheduling Order 16-22

More Definite Statement

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Oct 31, 2016 2014042524301 Order Regarding Respondent’s Motions to Stay Case Management and Scheduling Order and to Strike and/or For a More Definite Statement. 16-28
Dec 30, 2014 20080148227-02 Order Granting, in Part, and Denying in Part, Respondents 1, 4, 2’s Motions for More Definite Statement and Denying Respondent 3’s Motion for More Definite Statement 14-09
Dec 1, 2014 2011025676501 Order Granting, In Part, Motion for More Definite Statement 14-06
Jul 12, 2010 2008014621701 Order Granting Respondent 2's Motion to File a Reply and Denying Respondent 2's Motion for More Definite Statement 10-04
Dec 16, 2009 2008012955301 Order Denying Motion for More Definite Statement 09-05
Jul 2, 2007 2005000323905 Order Denying Respondent 1's Motion for a More Definite Statement 07-28
Feb 5, 2007 2005001305701 Order Denying the Respondents' Motion for a More Definite Statement 07-02
Nov 16, 2006 2005000316701 Order (1) Granting Complainant's Motion in Limine; (2) Denying Complainant's Motion to Sequester Witnesses, Without Prejudice; (3) Denying Respondents' Motions to Dismiss; (4) Denying Respondents' Motion to Strike; (5) Granting, in Part, Respondents' Motion To Preclude; (6) Denying, in Part, and Deferring, in Part, Respondents' Motion For Leave to Present Expert Testimony and (7) Denying Respondents' Motion for Leave to File a Compilation of Motions, Briefs and Rulings 06-55
Dec 19, 2005 E1020010426-04 Order Denying Motion for More Definite Statement 05-44
Jun 10, 2005 C9B050020 Order Conditionally Denying Motion for More Definite Statement 05-25
Jun 7, 2005 C05050015 Order Granting Respondent 2's Motion for More Definite Statement 05-24
Jun 7, 2005 C05050015 Order Denying Respondent 1's Motion for More Definite Statement 05-23
Sep 27, 2004 C9B040080 Order Denying Motion for a more Definite Statement 04-21
Sep 26, 2003 CLI030017 Order Granting Part Respondents' Motion for More Definite Statement 03-18
May 21, 2003 CAF030007 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Respondent's Motion for More Definite Statement 03-13
Dec 26, 2002 CAF020042 Order Denying Motion for More Definite Statement 02-12
Sep 28, 2000 C10000140 Order Denying Motion for More Definite Statement 00-27
Apr 4, 2000 C0500006 Order Granting in Part Respondent Motion for More Definite Statement 00-09
Mar 10, 2000 C3A990067 Order Denying Respondent Second Motion for More Definite Statement 00-06
Jan 20, 1998 C10970158 Order Denying Motion for More Definite Statement 98-8
Nov 28, 1997 CAF970002 Order Denying Motions for More Definite Statement 97-10
Oct 29, 1997 C10970160 Order Denying Motion for a More Definite Statement 97-5

Motions to Limit Discovery

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 5, 2012 2011029760201 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Leave to Serve Limited Discovery 12-02
Oct 10, 2000 CAF000030 Order Granting Enforcement's Motion for Leave to Withhold from Production Certain Documents and Granting Other Relief 00-31
Mar 28, 2000 C1000010 Order Granting Enforcement's Motion for Leave to Withhold From Production Certain Documents 00-08
Feb 17, 1998 C9B970016 Order Regarding Production Under Rule 9251 98-18

Oath

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jun 15, 2005 C3A040030 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Re-Open Hearing and Denying Complainant's Motion to Strike Respondent's Testimony 05-26

Office of Hearing Officers (OHO) topics

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 30, 2017 2013037401001 Sua Sponte Order Striking Portions of Respondent’s Answer and Precluding Immaterial and Impertinent Evidence 17-01

Official Notice / Issue Preclusion

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Aug 9, 2007 2005000323905 Order Regarding Respondent 2's Motions for Official Notice 07-35
Aug 4, 1998 CAF970011 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Complainant's Motion in Limine 98-26

Other Issues

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 28, 2016 2015044379701 Order Denying Motion to Dismiss 16-03
Mar 18, 2015 DFC140002 Order Granting Complainant’s Motion to Dismiss Hearing Request 15-01
Mar 28, 2007 CAF040079 Order Regarding Witnesses 07-13
Feb 28, 2007 2005001305701 Order Setting Philadelphia, Pa as Venue for Disciplinary Proceeding 07-08
Sep 15, 2006 ARB060023 Order Overruling Objection to Telephonic Hearing 06-39
Sep 1, 2006 E0220030845-01 Order Requiring Counsel to File Notice Pursuant to Rule 9142 06-34
Sep 27, 1999 C02990022 Order Denying Respondent's Request for Financial Assistance to Attend Hearing 99-17
Sep 21, 1999 CAF980002 Order Regarding Court Reporting Services for the Hearing 99-15
Feb 25, 1998 C10970033 Order Directing Written Submissions in Place of Hearing 98-19

Post-Complaint (and Pre-Complaint) Use of Rule 8210

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 11, 2017 2014044985401 Order Granting Respondent’s Request for an Order of Production. 17-11
Dec 28, 2016 2014042690502 Order Granting, in Part, Respondents' Motion Requesting Issuance of FINRA Rule 8210 Requests. 16-34
Feb 13, 2015 2013036217601 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Enforcement’s Motion to Compel Respondent’s Compliance with a Post-Complaint Rule 8210 Request for Testimony 15-03
Mar 13, 2013 2011026874301 Memorandum Order Directing Respondent to Comply with Rule 8210 Request for Information Regarding Respondent’s Reliance on Counsel Defense 13-02
Oct 31, 2007 20070077587 Order Resolving Certain Pre-Hearing Motions 07-38
Jun 13, 2007 2006004494201 Order Quashing Post-Complaint Rule 8210 Request for Information 07-23
May 11, 2007 2005001449202 Interim Scheduling and Case Management Order 07-18
Apr 25, 2006 CLG050021 Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference and Ruling on Motions in Limine 06-32
Jun 30, 2005 C05050015 Order Denying Motions to Quash 05-27
Mar 14, 2005 CAF040079 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Quash and Motion for a Protective Order 05-07
Nov 4, 2003 CAF030008 Order Granting Respondent's Motion to Quash Rule 8210 Request 03-23
Feb 14, 2001 CAF000045 Order Granting Motions to Quash 01-04
Jan 23, 2001 C10000172 Order Denying Motion to Quash 01-01
Aug 2, 2000 C3A990071 Protective Order Regarding Complainant's Rule 8210 Requests to Respondents 00-21
Sep 27, 1999 CAF980002 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Reconsideration Regarding Invocation of Rule 8210 Pursuant to Rule 9252 99-18
Apr 14, 1999 CAF980002 Order Granting Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Rule 8210 Request, and Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Personnel File and to Preclude Enforcement's Exhibits 99-06
May 6, 1998 C10970141 Order Granting Respondents' "Objection to Rule 8210 Requests" and Denying Motion of Respondents to File Reply Memorandum 98-23

Post-Hearing Evidence

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jun 15, 2005 C3A040030 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Re-Open Hearing and Denying Complainant's Motion to Strike Respondent's Testimony 05-26
Aug 27, 1999 C02980024 Order Granting Complainant's Motion to Strike 99-14

Pre-Hearing Depositions

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Mar 30, 2005 CAF040002 Order Denying in Part The Department's Motion for Leave to Offer Testimony by Telephone and Denying the Respondents' Motion Pursuant to Rule 9252 05-12
Jun 10, 2004 C9B040020 Order Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Discovery 04-04

Pre-Hearing Submissions (including exhibits, exhibit lists and witness lists)

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Feb 15, 2007 2005000316701 Order Ruling on Department of Enforcement's (1) Objections to Witnesses and Documents, (2) Motion to Partially Strike Respondents' Pre-Hearing Brief, (3) Motion in Limine, and (4) Motion for Ruling on the Admissibility of Documents and Business Records 07-04
Feb 1, 2007 E3A20050065 Order Regarding Respondent's Pre-Hearing Submissions 07-01
Mar 23, 2006 E102003130804 Order Regarding Respondent's Pre-Hearing Submissions 06-27
Feb 24, 2005 C3A040023 Order Regarding Respondents' Pre-Hearing Submissions 05-03
Oct 12, 2004 CAF040056 Order Rejecting Filing 04-27
Oct 4, 2004 C9B040036 Order Granting Respondents Rule 9261(C) Request 04-22
Sep 15, 2004 CAF030067 Order Denying Motion to Strike Witnesses 04-19
Sep 13, 2004 C3A030049 Order Precluding Evidence 04-18
Mar 19, 2003 C3A020039 Order Regarding Complainant's Motion for a Preclusion Order 03-04
Feb 13, 2001 C10000122 Order Regarding Complainant's Motion for a Preclusion Order 01-03
Jan 6, 1999 CAF980002 Order Denying "Notice of Objection to Order" and Rejecting "Response to Order to Show Cause" of Respondents 99-01
Jan 20, 1998 C10970161 Order 98-7
Dec 15, 1997 CMS970028 Order Granting in Part Complainant's Motion to Exclude Witnesses and Amend Exhibit List 97-12

Preclusion Orders

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 30, 2017 2013037401001 Sua Sponte Order Striking Portions of Respondent’s Answer and Precluding Immaterial and Impertinent Evidence 17-01
Feb 16, 2016 20080148227-02 Order Denying Respondents’ Preclusion Motion 16-05
Dec 22, 2015 2014040968501 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Enforcement's Motion in Limine to Preclude the Respondent from Introducing Testimony and Evidence at the Hearing 15-15
Sep 21, 2015 20080148227-02 Order Granting Respondents’ Preclusion Motion 15-12
Nov 11, 2009 2007007255603 Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference and Granting, in Part, Enforcement's Motion to Preclude Testimony and Exhibits 09-03
Nov 7, 2006 E1020040926-01 Order Precluding the Respondents from Presenting Witnesses at the Hearing, Other Than Respondent 2 06-52
Oct 31, 2006 2005000127502 Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference Modifying Order Precluding Respondents from Introducing Evidence at the Hearing and Dismissing the Third Cause of Complaint 06-50
Mar 23, 2006 CLI050007 Order Precluding Evidence and Denying Respondent's Motion to Continue Hearing 06-28
Jan 12, 2006 C07050029 Order Denying Complainant's Motion to Preclude the Respondent from Offering Evidence, Revising the Pre-Hearing Schedule, and Denying Respondent's Motion to Reconsider Denial of Motion to Compel Discovery 06-08
Nov 18, 2005 CAF040058 Order Regarding Admissibility of Tape Recordings and Transcripts 05-40
Mar 29, 2005 C01040017 Order Granting in Part the Department's Motion to Preclude the Respondent from Introducing Evidence at the Hearing 05-11
Oct 28, 2004 CAF040020 Order Ruling On Pre-Hearing Motions 04-29
Sep 15, 2004 CAF030067 Order Denying Motion to Strike Witnesses 04-19
Sep 13, 2004 C3A030049 Order Precluding Evidence 04-18
Mar 17, 2004 CAF030014 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition and Request for Preclusion Order Based Upon Unfair Investigatory Process 04-01
Dec 22, 2003 03-03 Hearing Panel Decision as to Respondent
Sep 8, 2003 03-02 Hearing Panel Decision as to Respondent
Mar 19, 2003 C3A020039 Order Regarding Complainant's Motion for a Preclusion Order 03-04
Jan 17, 2003 CAF020007 Order Granting Motion for Reconsideration 03-02
Apr 23, 2002 CAF000027 Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference 02-06
Feb 13, 2001 C10000122 Order Regarding Complainant's Motion for a Preclusion Order 01-03
Jan 6, 1999 CAF980002 Order Denying "Notice of Objection to Order" and Rejecting "Response to Order to Show Cause" of Respondents 99-01
Jan 20, 1998 C10970161 Order 98-7

Privileges

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Mar 7, 2007 2005000316701 Order Granting Motion to Compel or Alternatively to Preclude Oral or Documentary Evidence 07-09
Jun 30, 2005 C05050015 Order Denying Motions to Quash 05-27
Oct 6, 2004 CAF040002 Motion To Compel Compliance With Procedural Rule 9251 and Denying the Respondents' Motions for Sanctions and for Leave to File a Reply 04-26
Sep 8, 2003 03-02 Hearing Panel Decision as to Respondent
Jan 17, 2003 CAF020007 Order Granting Motion for Reconsideration 03-02
Jan 30, 2002 C3A010036 Order Denying Respondents' Motion For Order Directing Enforcement To Produce Documents 02-03

Protective Orders

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 25, 2018 2015046971701 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion for Leave to Offer Telephone or Videoconference Testimony 18-04
Jul 28, 2016 2013035817701 Protective Order Governing Personal Confidential Information 16-19
Oct 1, 2015 2013035344201 Protective Order Governing Personal Confidential Information 15-13
Jul 16, 2014 2012033128703 Order Granting Motion to Limit Dissemination and Use of Personal Confidential Information 14-02
Apr 8, 2010 200500224102 Order Limiting the Dissemination of Personal, Confidential Information 10-01
Oct 31, 2007 20070077587 Order Resolving Certain Pre-Hearing Motions 07-38
Oct 11, 2005 CAF040058 Order Granting Joint Motion for a Protective Order 05-33
May 17, 2005 C9B040098 Order Denying Relief Sought in Notice to Produce and Application for Protective Order 05-20
Mar 17, 2005 CMS040202 Order Denying Motion for Order to Cease and Desist 05-08
Aug 19, 2003 03-01 Hearing Panel Decision as to Respondent
Jan 6, 2003 CAF020041 Order Granting the Department of Enforcement's Motion for a Protective Order 03-01
May 11, 2001 C05010012 Order Granting Respondent's Request for Production of Documents Pursuant to NASD Procedural Rule 9252 01-12

Relevance

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 30, 2017 2013037401001 Sua Sponte Order Striking Portions of Respondent’s Answer and Precluding Immaterial and Impertinent Evidence 17-01
Jun 11, 2007 E102003025201 Order Ruling on (1) Objections to Witnesses, (2) Motion to Substitute Exhibit, (3) Motions in Limine, and (4) Motions to Strike the Respondents' Affirmative Defenses 07-21
Feb 15, 2007 2005000316701 Order Ruling on Department of Enforcement's (1) Objections to Witnesses and Documents, (2) Motion to Partially Strike Respondents' Pre-Hearing Brief, (3) Motion in Limine, and (4) Motion for Ruling on the Admissibility of Documents and Business Records 07-04
Dec 28, 2006 E8A2003084806 Order Granting Complainant's Motion in Limine 06-58
Nov 16, 2006 2005000316701 Order (1) Granting Complainant's Motion in Limine; (2) Denying Complainant's Motion to Sequester Witnesses, Without Prejudice; (3) Denying Respondents' Motions to Dismiss; (4) Denying Respondents' Motion to Strike; (5) Granting, in Part, Respondents' Motion To Preclude; (6) Denying, in Part, and Deferring, in Part, Respondents' Motion For Leave to Present Expert Testimony and (7) Denying Respondents' Motion for Leave to File a Compilation of Motions, Briefs and Rulings 06-55
Jan 13, 2006 CLI050016 Order Granting, In Part, Complainant's Motion to Preclude and Denying Respondent's Motion to Limit Complainant's Evidence 06-12
Oct 29, 2003 CAF030008 Order Regarding the Department's Motions in Limine 03-22
Apr 30, 2003 CMS020143 Order Denying Complainant's Motion in Limine 03-11
Feb 15, 2001 CMS000157 Order Granting Respondent's Motion to Exclude Documents 01-05
Mar 10, 1998 C05970035 Order Granting in Part Motion of Complainant to Exclude Respondents' Expert Witness and Certain Other Witnesses 98-22

Remand

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Sep 30, 1999 CMS920002 Order Directing Complainant to Comply with Rule 9251 99-19

Remedies / Sanctions / Settlements

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Aug 15, 2016 2013038986001 Order Rejecting Offer of Settlement 16-21
Mar 27, 2008 C02050006 Order Approving and Forwarding Contested Offer of Settlement 08-05
Dec 28, 2006 E8A2003084806 Order Granting Complainant's Motion in Limine 06-58
Mar 12, 2006 CAF040079 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition 06-23
Aug 5, 2005 C3A040045 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition on the Issue of Restitution 05-30
Apr 30, 2003 C3B020015 Order Rejecting Contested Offer of Settlement 03-12
Sep 6, 2000 C8A000019 Order Convening Settlement Conference 00-25
Mar 1, 2000 C05990026 Order Rejecting Contested Offer of Settlement 00-04

Replacement of Hearing Officers

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Dec 10, 2014 2011026386001 Order Appointing Replacement Hearing Officer, Amending Caption, and Setting Hearing Dates 14-08

Representation

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 30, 2010 2008013503101 Order Denying Respondent's Motions for Leave to Seek and Retain Counsel and to Adjourn and Retain Counsel 10-02
Mar 16, 2007 C02050006 Order Requiring Counsel to File Notice of Representation or Withdrawal 07-10
Dec 22, 2003 03-03 Hearing Panel Decision as to Respondent
Jan 14, 2003 C9A020018 Order Denying Request for Postponement of Hearing 03-03
Jan 21, 1998 C10970176 Order as to Respondent 98-10
Dec 9, 1997 C10970128 Order Regarding Department of Enforcements Contact with Respondent's Counsel 97-11
Oct 7, 1997 C3A970066 Order Granting Motion to Withdraw as Counsel to Respondent 97-3

Rule 9251 Compliance

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Dec 20, 2017 2016047565702 Order Regarding Motion for Order Directing Zipper to File a Proposed Answer 17-14
Mar 21, 2017 2014038847602 Order Denying Motion to Quash and Requiring Respondent to Respond to Rule 8210 Requests No Later Than March 31, 2017. 17-08
Mar 8, 2017 2015044921601 Order Denying Respondent’s Discovery Motion. 17-04
Dec 14, 2016 2015044823501 Order Denying Respondent Beyn’s Motion for Additional Discovery. 16-33
Feb 23, 2015 2010024522103 Order Denying Respondents’ Motion Pursuant to Rule 9251 15-02
Feb 15, 2008 2005003437102 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Compel Production of Documents 08-01
Jul 13, 2007 2005001919501 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Compel Production of Exculpatory and Other Material Documents 07-29
Jun 26, 2007 20050000720-02 Order Denying Respondent 2's Motion to Compel Production of Documents and Directing Respondent 2 to Supplement His Motion for a Rule 9252 Order 07-25
Jun 11, 2007 CAF040079 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Preclude Evidence and Requiring Enforcement to File a Declaration 07-19
Feb 1, 2006 C02040032 Order Denying Motion to Dismiss 06-16
Jan 12, 2006 E8A2003080701 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Discovery 06-09
Oct 11, 2005 C9B050022 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Discovery 05-34
Jun 23, 2005 C3A040045 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Compel and Motion Pursuant to Rule 9252 05-28
Oct 4, 2001 CAF000045 Order Regarding Production of Documents 01-16
Aug 28, 2000 C3A990071 Order Granting Respondents Motion in Limine Requesting Production of Documents 00-24
Jun 21, 1999 CAF980002 Order Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Documents 99-12
Apr 14, 1999 CAF980002 Order Granting Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Rule 8210 Request, and Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Personnel File and to Preclude Enforcement's Exhibits 99-06
Apr 13, 1999 CMS980108 Order with Respect to Respondent's Motion to Compel Production of Documents 99-05
Feb 25, 1998 CAF970002 Order Regarding Motion of Respondents and Enforcement's Motion to Strike 98-20
Jan 2, 1998 C10970158 Order Denying Motion to Compel Discovery 98-2

Selection of Hearing Officers

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Nov 26, 2007 2005000323905 Order Denying Motion (1) to Reassign, (2) for Additional Information Regarding Panelists, (3) to Permit Discovery and (4) for a Delay in the Hearing 07-39

Selection of Hearing Panelists

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 8, 2015 2010024522103 Order Denying Motion Pursuant to FINRA Rule 9234 15-09
Nov 26, 2007 2005000323905 Order Denying Motion (1) to Reassign, (2) for Additional Information Regarding Panelists, (3) to Permit Discovery and (4) for a Delay in the Hearing 07-39
Jan 17, 2006 CLG050021 Order Denying Complainant's Motion for Appointment of Market Regulation Panelist 06-10
Oct 30, 2005 CAF040079 Order Denying Motion to Reconsider Appointment of Extended Hearing Panelists 05-36

Sequestration

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Aug 30, 2016 2014043020901 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion for Exception From Sequestration. 16-24
Jul 6, 2012 2010024889501 Order Granting Department of Enforcement’s Motion Regarding Sequestration of FINRA Staff Witnesses 12-03
Feb 29, 2008 20070077587 Rulings on Pre-Hearing Motions and Notice of Hearing 08-03
Nov 16, 2006 2005000316701 Order (1) Granting Complainant's Motion in Limine; (2) Denying Complainant's Motion to Sequester Witnesses, Without Prejudice; (3) Denying Respondents' Motions to Dismiss; (4) Denying Respondents' Motion to Strike; (5) Granting, in Part, Respondents' Motion To Preclude; (6) Denying, in Part, and Deferring, in Part, Respondents' Motion For Leave to Present Expert Testimony and (7) Denying Respondents' Motion for Leave to File a Compilation of Motions, Briefs and Rulings 06-55
Nov 9, 2006 EAF0300770001 Order For Sequestration of Witnesses 06-53
Mar 9, 2006 CAF040079 Order Granting Enforcement's Motion for Witness Sequestration 06-22
Dec 15, 1997 CMS970028 Order Granting in Part Complainant's Motion to Exclude Witnesses and Amend Exhibit List 97-12
Nov 15, 1997 C07970055 Final Pre-hearing Conference Order 97-9

Service

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Oct 10, 2006 EAF0400300001 Order Directing the Parties to Cease Sending Non-Compliant Communications to the Office of Hearing Officers 06-46
Sep 15, 2006 ARB060023 Order Overruling Objection to Telephonic Hearing 06-39
Apr 6, 2001 C07000084 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Reconsider and to Set Aside Default Decision 01-06
Mar 26, 2000 CAF980002 Order Regarding Respondents' Motion to Preclude Designation of Transcripts; Respondents' Motion for a Protective Order; and Enforcement's Motion for Post-Hearing Submissions in Excess of Twenty-Five Pages 00-07
Mar 9, 2000 C8A990032 Order Vacating Default Against Respondent, Granting Complainant Leave to Re-Serve the Complaint, and Setting a Briefing Schedule on the Issue of Jurisdiction 00-05
Sep 23, 1999 C02980034 Order Denying Motion for Entry Of Default Decision Against Respondent and Granting Enforcement Leave to Re-Serve the Complaint 99-16

State Actor Issue

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 18, 2007 C11040006 Hearing Panel Order Granting, in Part, and Denying, in Part, Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition 07-16
Jan 30, 2002 C3A010036 Order Denying Respondents' Motion For Order Directing Enforcement To Produce Documents 02-03

Stipulations and Statements of Undisputed Facts

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Mar 20, 2005 CAF030058 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Deem Admitted Statement of Undisputed Facts Supporting Motion for Summary Disposition 05-09
Sep 15, 2004 CAF030067 Order Denying Motion to Strike Witnesses 04-19
May 21, 2002 C07010100 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Strike Complainant's Pleadings and for Imposition of Sanctions 02-11
Jul 20, 1998 C10970141 Order Regarding Pre-Hearing Conference 98-25
Jan 21, 1998 C04970029 Order Establishing Procedure for Arriving at Stipulations and Re-Scheduling Pre-Hearing Conference 98-9

Strike, Motions to

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Jan 10, 2018 2014041860801 Order Denying Respondents’ Motion for More Definite Statement and Department of Enforcement’s Motion to Strike 18-05
Apr 7, 2017 2012035284301 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion to Strike Respondent’s Post-Hearing Affidavit and Exhibits and Ordering Respondent to Resubmit Post-Hearing Brief. 17-09
Jan 30, 2017 2013037401001 Sua Sponte Order Striking Portions of Respondent’s Answer and Precluding Immaterial and Impertinent Evidence 17-01
Oct 31, 2016 2014042524301 Order Regarding Respondent’s Motions to Stay Case Management and Scheduling Order and to Strike and/or For a More Definite Statement. 16-28
Sep 13, 2016 2012033105901 Order Granting Department of Enforcement’s Motion to Strike Affirmative Defense. 16-26
May 24, 2016 2014043020901 Order Ruling on Witness Objections 16-18
Jun 4, 2015 2011025444501 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Strike Portions of Enforcement's Post-Hearing Appendix 15-10
Dec 8, 2014 2011030781201 Order (1) Denying Respondent’s Motion to Dismiss, (2) Granting in Part Enforcement’s Motion to Strike, and (3) Directing Respondent to File an Amended Answer 14-07
Oct 23, 2012 2011026664301 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part the Department of Enforcement’s Motion to Strike the Answer and Order the Filing of a New Answer 12-06
May 21, 2002 C07010100 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Strike Complainant's Pleadings and for Imposition of Sanctions 02-11
Feb 13, 2001 C10000122 Order Regarding Complainant's Motion for a Preclusion Order 01-03
Jan 26, 2001 CAF000045 Order Denying Complainant's Motion to Strike Affirmative Defenses 01-02
Aug 27, 1999 C02980024 Order Granting Complainant's Motion to Strike 99-14
Feb 25, 1998 CAF970002 Order Regarding Motion of Respondents and Enforcement's Motion to Strike 98-20

Summary Disposition Motions

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Apr 11, 2018 2014040761001 Amended Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Partial Summary Disposition 18-01
Feb 7, 2017 2014042291901 Order Denying Respondents’ Motion for Summary Disposition. 17-02
Nov 4, 2016 2014039839101 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion for Partial Summary Disposition. 16-29
Oct 14, 2016 201303641201 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Enforcement’s Motion for Partial Summary Disposition 16-27
Mar 10, 2016 2012031496501 Order Denying Respondents’ Motion for Partial Summary Disposition. 16-11
Mar 4, 2016 2014040501801 Order Denying Respondents’ Motion for Summary Disposition 16-09
Mar 3, 2016 2014040968501 Omnibus Order on Pre-Hearing Motions 16-13
Feb 26, 2016 2014041724601 Order Denying Respondents’ Motions 1) For Summary Disposition and 2) To Disqualify Enforcement Counsel 16-16
Apr 2, 2015 2013036217601 Order Granting In Part and Denying In Part Enforcement’s Motion for Partial Summary Disposition 15-07
Jun 17, 2014 2011026788801 Order Denying Summary Disposition 14-01
Feb 8, 2011 2006007105101 Order Denying Respondent’s Motion for Summary Disposition 11-02
Aug 8, 2008 E3A20030495-01 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Dismiss the Complaint 08-11
Jun 12, 2008 2005001798201 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition 08-10
Jun 12, 2008 20070094345 and 20070111775 Order Denying Respondent 2's Motion to Dismiss 08-09
Apr 4, 2008 2005003437102 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition 08-07
Oct 16, 2007 2005001919501 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition and Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition 07-37
Apr 18, 2007 C11040006 Hearing Panel Order Granting, in Part, and Denying, in Part, Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition 07-16
Mar 22, 2007 C10040052 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Partial Summary Disposition 07-11
Nov 16, 2006 2005000316701 Order (1) Granting Complainant's Motion in Limine; (2) Denying Complainant's Motion to Sequester Witnesses, Without Prejudice; (3) Denying Respondents' Motions to Dismiss; (4) Denying Respondents' Motion to Strike; (5) Granting, in Part, Respondents' Motion To Preclude; (6) Denying, in Part, and Deferring, in Part, Respondents' Motion For Leave to Present Expert Testimony and (7) Denying Respondents' Motion for Leave to File a Compilation of Motions, Briefs and Rulings 06-55
Oct 20, 2006 2005000127502 Order Denying Complainant's Motion for Partial Summary Disposition 06-48
Oct 9, 2006 20042000056-01 Order Deferring Ruling on Motion for Summary Disposition 06-45
Mar 12, 2006 CAF040079 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition 06-23
Aug 5, 2005 C3A040045 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition on the Issue of Restitution 05-30
Mar 20, 2005 CAF030058 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Deem Admitted Statement of Undisputed Facts Supporting Motion for Summary Disposition 05-09
Jul 7, 2004 C8A030100 Order Granting in Part and Deferring in Part Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition, and Denying Respondents' Motion for Summary Disposition 04-11
Jun 24, 2004 CAF030055 Order Denying Enforcement's Motion for Summary Disposition 04-08
Mar 17, 2004 CAF030014 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Disposition and Request for Preclusion Order Based Upon Unfair Investigatory Process 04-01
Jun 4, 2003 C9A030006 Order Denying Motion for Summary Disposition 03-15
Apr 3, 2003 C3B020015 Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition 03-06
May 14, 2002 C01010009 Order Deferring Decision On Complainant's Motion For Summary Disposition 02-09
May 1, 2001 C3A000056 Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration 01-10
Apr 20, 2001 C3A000056 Order Denying Motion to Dismiss, in Part, Deferring Decision on Motion, in Part, and Directing Enforcement to Supplement its Opposition 01-09
Apr 17, 2001 CAF000013 Order Denying Respondents' Motion for Summary Disposition and Motion to Dismiss the Fourth Cause of Action and Supplementing Order Granting Complainant's Motion for Summary Disposition on Cause Four of the Complaint Against Respondents 01-07
Jul 6, 2000 C3A990067 Order Denying Motion for Summary Disposition 00-16
Jan 4, 2000 C10990121 Order Denying Enforcement's Motion For Summary Disposition 00-01
Dec 30, 1999 CAF990018 Order Denying Motion for Summary Disposition 99-21
Dec 26, 1997 CAF970001 Order Regarding Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings 97-17

Telephone Testimony

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Nov 13, 2017 2015047154001 Order Denying Respondent’s Amended Motion to Grant Expert Testimony 17-19
Nov 13, 2017 2013035345701 Order Sustaining Department of Enforcement’s Objection to Respondents’ Inclusion of Erin Vocke on their Proposed Witness List 17-20
Feb 7, 2017 2014042291901 Order Denying Respondents’ Motion for Summary Disposition. 17-02
Oct 22, 2015 201203564701 Order Granting, in Part, Enforcement's Motion for Leave to Offer Telephone Testimony 15-14
Feb 22, 2007 E8A2002109804 Order Granting the Parties' Motions for Telephone Testimony and Deferring Ruling on Respondent's Objection to Enforcement's Proposed Exhibit CX-7 07-07
Apr 25, 2006 CLG050021 Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference and Ruling on Motions in Limine 06-32
Mar 8, 2006 CAF040079 Order Granting Enforcement's Motion to Offer Testimony Via Telephone 06-21
Oct 30, 2005 C3A040045 Order (1) Granting Complainant's Motion for Leave to Offer Telephone Testimony and Denying Respondent's Motion to Postpone the Hearing; (2) Granting Complainant's Motion in Limine; and (3) Denying Respondent's Motion in Limine 05-37
Apr 25, 2005 C07040084 Order Granting Complainant's Motion for Telephone Testimony 05-18
Mar 30, 2005 CAF040002 Order Denying in Part The Department's Motion for Leave to Offer Testimony by Telephone and Denying the Respondents' Motion Pursuant to Rule 9252 05-12
Aug 25, 2004 C3A030050 Order Granting Motion for Leave to Offer Telephone Testimony 04-15
Aug 2, 2004 CAF040056 Order Granting in Part, and Denying in Part, Enforcement's Motion for Leave to Offer Telephone Testimony 04-13
Apr 23, 2004 C9B040033 Pre-Hearing Order 04-24
Apr 23, 2002 CAF000027 Order Following Final Pre-Hearing Conference 02-06
Dec 26, 2000 C10000122 Order Granting Motion to Allow Telephone Testimony 00-32
Oct 5, 2000 C05000021 Order Granting Complainant's Motion for Leave to Offer Telephone Testimony and to Allow Witness to be Assisted by (Remote) Interpreter 00-28
Jan 18, 2000 C02990052 Order Granting Enforcement's Motion for Leave to Offer Telephone Testimony 00-02
Oct 26, 1998 C3A980027 Order Granting Complainant's Motion for Leave to Offer Telephone Testimony 98-30
Feb 25, 1998 CAF970002 Order Regarding Motion of Respondents and Enforcement's Motion to Strike 98-20
Jan 27, 1998 C3A970067 Order Granting Department of Enforcement's Motion for Telephone Testimony 98-13
Jan 22, 1998 CMS970026 Order Granting the Department of Enforcement's Motion for Telephone Testimony, Denying Respondents' Motion for Use of an Expert Witness and Denying Respondents' Motion to Compel Production of Documents 98-11

Withheld Document Lists

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Mar 29, 2005 C02040044 Order Denying Motion for List of Documents Withheld 05-10
Jun 14, 2000 C8A000022 Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Withheld Document List 00-14
Feb 25, 1998 CAF970002 Order Regarding Motion of Respondents and Enforcement's Motion to Strike 98-20
Jan 2, 1998 C10970158 Order Denying Motion to Compel Discovery 98-2

Witnesses

Back to Top
Date of Decision Proceeding No. Title Order No.
Aug 30, 2016 2014043020901 Order Granting Enforcement’s Motion for Exception From Sequestration. 16-24
Aug 24, 2016 2014043020901 Order Granting Joint Motion to Permit Witnesses to Have Counsel Present During Testimony 16-23