SEC Approves Rule Amendment Requiring That ADF Market Participant Provide Advance Written Notice When Denying Access
Alternative Display Facility (ADF)
Effective Date: October 20, 2004
Legal & Compliance
Alternative Display System (ADF)
On August 18, 2004, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) approved amendments to Rule 4300A to require Alternative Display Facility (ADF) Market Participants to provide written notice, via facsimile, personal delivery, courier, or overnight mail, at least 14 calendar days in advance to NASD's ADF Market Operations before denying direct electronic access to an NASD member firm.1 Upon receipt of the notice, ADF Market Operations will post the required notice on the ADF Web page to ensure that member firms have adequate time to make other routing or access arrangements, as necessary. Amended Rule 4300A also provides that only a Market Participant that is an electronic communications network (ECN) may lawfully deny access to its quotes, and may only do so in the limited circumstance where a broker-dealer fails to pay contractually obligated costs for access to the ECN's quotes.
The text of the amendments is set forth in Attachment A and becomes effective on October 20,2004.
Questions concerning this Notice may be directed to Patricia Albrecht, Assistant General Counsel, Office of General Counsel, Regulatory Policy and Oversight (202) 728-8026; or Elliot Levine, Chief Counsel, Markets, Services, and Information, at (202) 728-8405.
The ADF is a quotation collection, trade comparison, and trade reporting facility developed by NASD in accordance with the SEC's SuperMontage Approval Order.2 The ADF currently is operating as a pilot until October 26, 2004,3 and it is anticipated that the ADF will continue to operate on a pilot basis until the SEC approves the operation of the ADF on a permanent basis.
ADF provides Market Participants (e.g., ADF-registered market makers or ECNs) the ability to post quotations in NASDAQ securities and provides all member firms that participate in the ADF the ability to view quotations and report transactions in NASDAQ securities to the Securities Information Processor (SIP) for NASDAQ-listed issues for consolidation and dissemination of data to vendors and ADF Market Participants. The facility also provides for trade comparison through the Trade Reporting and Comparison Service (TRACS). The facility further provides for real-time data delivery to NASD for regulatory purposes, including enforcement of firm quote and related rules.
The ADF does not provide an order-routing capability. Instead, Rule 4300A requires Market Participants to provide direct electronic access to other Market Participants and to provide to all other NASD member firms direct electronic access or allow for indirect electronic access to the individual market participant's quote. This rule provides the means for Market Participants and other broker/dealers to access ADF quotes and, among other things, meet the firm quote and locked and crossed quotation requirements. Rule 4300A prohibits Market Participants from in any way discouraging or discriminating against member firms that wish to reach their quotes.
Last year, NASD became aware that a Market Participant denied access, with no prior notice, to a second ADF Market Participant for allegedly failing to pay contractually obligated costs. This action caused disruption not only for the Market Participant denied access, but also other NASD member firms that typically accessed the first Market Participant's quote through the second ADF Market Participant's routing system. Although there were other means in place by which an NASD member firm could access the first Market Participant's quotes, the absence of any advance notice of the denial of access caused confusion in the marketplace as member firms considered alternative means to access the first Market Participant's quotes.
Accordingly, to maintain market efficiency and prevent such confusion in the future, NASD has amended Rule 4300A to require that Market Participants provide written notice, via facsimile, personal delivery, courier, or overnight mail, at least 14 calendar days in advance to ADF Market Operations before denying access to an NASD member firm. The 14-day period begins on the first business day that ADF Market Operations has receipt of the notice. Upon receipt of the notice, ADF Market Operations will post the notice on the ADF Web page to ensure that member firms have adequate time to make other routing or access arrangements, as necessary. To ensure proper documentation of compliance with Rule 4300A, member firms should maintain evidence of receipt of the notice (i.e., dated facsimile confirmation, receipt from a courier, etc.).
Rule 4300A also codifies existing NASD guidance that a Market Participant may deny access to its quotes only in the limited circumstances where a broker-dealer fails to pay contractually obligated costs for access to its quotes.4 Because the SEC has determined that only ECNs may charge a post-transaction fee for execution against their displayed quotation (i.e., access fee),5Rule 4300A clarifies that only Market Participants that are ECNs may deny access to an NASD member firm for failure to pay contractually obligated access fees.
Additionally, any denial of access must be based on a good faith belief that the denial of access is appropriate and does not violate any NASD rules or the securities laws. Amended Rule 4300A further clarifies that the publication of an ADF Market Participant's intent to deny access will have no bearing on the merits of any claim between the Market Participant and any affected broker-dealer, nor will it insulate the Market Participant from liability from violations of NASD rules or the federal securities laws, such as SEC Rule 11Ac1-1. If NASD believes that a Market Participant has improperly denied a broker-dealer access to its quotes, the Market Participant will not have met the terms of Rule 4300A. In that instance, NASD will consider the ADF Market Participant to be in violation of that provision and will not permit the ADF Market Participant to continue quoting on the ADF.
1 Exchange Act Rel. No. 50218 (August 18, 2004), 69 F.R. 52055 (August 24, 2004) (File No. SRNASD- 2004-002).
2 Exchange Act Rel. No. 43863 (January 19, 2001), 66 F.R. 8020 (January 26, 2001) (File No. SRNASD- 99-53).
3See Exchange Act Rel. No. 49131 (January 27, 2004), 69 F.R. 5229 (February 3, 2004) (File No. SR-NASD-2004-12).
4 See Exchange Act Rel. No. 46249 (July 24, 2002), 67 F.R. 49822 (July 31, 2002) (File No. SR-NASD- 2002-97).
5See Letter from Robert L.D. Colby, Deputy Director, Division of Market Regulation, SEC, to Louis B. Todd, Jr., Head of Equity Trading, J.C. Bradford & Co. (August 6, 1998).
* * * * *